The Difference Between These Best-Selling Benefit Brow Products Under $45
Amy Clark is Adore Beauty's former Senior Editor and co-host of Skincare School the podcast (and self-appointed beauty road-tester!). Amy's worked as a journalist, beauty editor and podcaster for several years, previously writing and talking about all things beauty at Mamamia and You Beauty. When she's not writing honest, no BS product reviews and taking selfies 'for work', you'll find Amy eating halloumi in a hair towel turban and... taking more selfies.
If there’s one brand that truly has it all when it comes to brows, it’s Benefit.
From brow pencils and tinted brow gels to brow pomades and powders, there are so many products to choose from...
So if you're feeling confused or overwhelmed about finding the best brow product for you, don't stress.
Keep scrolling for your ultimate guide to Benefit brow products, including reviews on the most popular eyebrow products to help you find The One.
Watch our Benefit brow products comparison YouTube video below, or read on for all the details.
Best Benefit Brow Products.
The beauty of Benefit eyebrow products is there's literally one to suit everyone... and every brow.
Want a brow pencil to fill in over-plucked eyebrows? Try Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil or Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil.
Need a brow gel to keep your brow hairs standing up all day? You can't beat Benefit 24 Hour Brow Setter Clear Brow Gel or Benefit Gimme Brow + Volumizing Gel.
And don't even get me STARTED on how good the new Benefit Powmade Brow Pomade is!
OK, but how do I know which Benefit brow product is best for me, you ask?
Let's compare five of the brand's best-selling brow products.
1. Benefit Clear Brow Gel.
What:
- An iconic clear eyebrow gel that's been a best seller for years!
- Mascara-like wand helps you brush brows into shape.
- Invisible, flake-free formula locks hairs into place for up to 24 hours.
- Large tube is easy to use and will last you ages.
How to use it:
Wear the clear brow gel on its own for a low-key look, or layer it on top of other tinted brow gels, pencils and pomades to set your shape once you've filled your brows in.
Best for:
- Anyone who wants a quick and easy brow product that involves zero effort.
- If your brow hairs seem to fall down and won't stay in place.
- When you've had your eyebrows tinted and only need hold, rather than colour.
- Those with unruly, bushy or thick brows that don't need filling in.
If you'd like to see Benefit compared to other brand's brow gels, watch the below video:
2. Benefit POWmade Brow Pomade.
What:
- Benefit POWmade is a creamy, pigmented brow pomade that's legitimately easy to use.
- Highly-pigmented, non-drying formula lasts up to 36 hours.
- Water-resistant and smudge-proof.
- Pot comes with a built-in brush wiper that removes excess product.
- Available in 8 shades.
How to use it:
Brush brows upwards using a spoolie brush (naked mascara wand or brow brush).
Dip your Benefit Pomade Brush into the pomade and wipe excess product off on the in-built brush wiper.
Pro tip: Start off with less product on your brush than you think you'll need.
Wear on its own, or go over the top with Brow Setter for extra hold, or Gimme Brow to add more body and depth to sparse brows.
Best for:
Everyone! This multi-use product can be used to:
- Fill in sparse brows.
- Define unruly brows.
- Sculpt brows for a sleek look.
- Keep brows in place all damn day.
- You can read our full Benefit brow pomade review article here.
3. Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil.
What:
- Maybe the easiest to use brow pencil, ever!
- Versatile angled brow pencil tip creates both thin and wide brush strokes.
- Comes with an in-built spoolie brush on the other end.
- Creamy pencil glides on effortlessly and leaves a natural finish.
- Long-wearing formula comes in 12 shades!
How to use it:
To use, try the pointed edge for creating subtle strokes or defining brow tails. For more coverage, go for the wider edge.
Once you’ve applied your pencil, use the spoolie brush to blend it all through your brows. Again, you can add a Benefit brow gel over the top for extra hold!
Best for:
- People who feel like they don't know how to use brow products!
- If you need to fill in your brows, fast.
- Those with sparse brows who want to be able to create hair-like strokes OR quickly and easily fill in large gaps.
4. Benefit Gimme Brow.
What:
- This best-selling tinted brow gel is basically three eyebrow products in one.
- Over 508 customer reviews give this iconic brow gel a 4.6 stars out of five!
- Pigmented formula holds brows in place and comes in 10 shades.
- In-built microfibres adhere to skin and brows to minimise gaps and make brows look fuller.
- Tapered spoolie brush makes it easy to apply product precisely.
How to use it:
Want to know how to use Benefit brow gel? Simply sweep it on from brow roots to tips, similar to how you’d use mascara on your lashes.
Pro tip: Start with less product and build as you go. I like to wipe excess off on the side of the tube, and finish by brushing product through with a clean spoolie brush.
Best for:
- Want to fill in sparse brows, add colour and keep brows in place all day? This brow product has you covered.
- Adding volume to gappy brows, and layering over the top of other brow products.
- Great for when you're in-between eyebrow tinting appointments!
5. Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil.
What:
- The ultimate brow-defining pencil for filling in sparse brows.
- Ultra-fine tip draws incredibly natural-looking hair-like strokes, while the textured, custom-control grip gives extra control.
- Comes with an in-built spoolie brush on the other end.
- Soft, creamy formula is easy to draw on and stays in place all day.
- Comes in 12 shades!
How to use it:
Brush brow hairs into place using the provided spoolie brush so you can see where the gaps are.
Create short strokes to fill in sparse areas or empty spaces, and build up coverage around the tail of the brow to maintain a great shape. Finish with brow gel and you’re all set!
Best for:
- Drawing on eyebrow hairs where there aren't any.
- Anyone who over-plucked their eyebrows.
- Filling in teeny tiny gaps with strokes that look like real brow hairs.
- Creating a natural-looking eyebrow look - think your brows, but better.
How to Choose Your Eyebrow Colour.
Finally, some tips on choosing the best shade in your chosen brow product.
Really, the shade you choose comes down personal preference.
Some people will prefer a colour that contrasts their natural hair colour. Others might like to match their colouring.
Benefit brow products come in a range of shades from light blonde, light brown and auburn through to medium brown, dark brown, black and grey.
For a natural-looking brow, choose a shade similar or a bit darker than your natural brow in a neutral or warm undertone. Go for a shade two shades darker in a cooler undertone for a bold, more defined look.
And that's everything you need to know about Benefit brow products.
All that's left to do is to decide which one to add to cart...
Shop the Best Benefit Brow Products Here:
Want more brow product reviews? Check out these Beauty IQ articles below:
